A Good Foundation

About an 11 minute read

This sprint was defined by getting some good system foundations in place. These elements are now in a postion to be formed by the talented artists and designers on the team.

Tasks for this sprint:

  1. [ui] Create the pause menu system
  2. [tools] Make improvements to the playtest data explorer
  3. [tools] Create a system for automatic game builds

Creating the Pause Menu

I found this tutorial very helpful in creating a basic menu system. It covers some good layout patterns and tools, intro and transition animations, and a small script to tie it all together. I used this to build a frame for the menus to be filled with content. I also updated the existing button and slider prefabs to fit within this framework, then created the first menu sample.

implementation of the generic menu
First implementation of the generic menu

This was a nice start, but pretty unattractive. It also had a poor experience based on the default event system configuration. First, there are several states of “selectable” items, like the buttons and sliders. There is a state for an option being selected, which represents the pre-button-press stage for gamepad inputs, but post-click for mouse inputs. There is another state, highlighted, which indicates the pre-click hover state for mouse inputs, but nothing for gamepads. The system doesn’t intuitively switch between utilizing these states even though it can handle automatically switching inputs.

The fix for this was to manually make some adjustments from the menu manager. First, upon opening a menu, if the input is a gamepad, we need to select an item so navigation from the gamepad can work. This doesn’t click the button, but makes places the navigation cursor there. Secondly, whenever the menu system is closed, we deselect whatever the current selection was. This clears the state from the mouse click, which persisted between menu opens.

if (input.currentControlScheme == "Gamepad")
    eventSystem.SetSelectedGameObject(menu.topItem, null);

if (menu == null)
    eventSystem.SetSelectedGameObject(null, null);

I also made some stylistic updates, changing the design and animation and using a screenshot from the game as some visual context.

The restyled menu

There were still a few more issues yet. First, I substituted the placeholder triangle image for a leaf image, updated the slider selected style to differentiate which input is selected, and introduced a debounce library to deal with quick input events.

To elaborate, we recieve a lot of events from every gamepad input. This makes a lot of sense for controling the player as it offers fast response times. However, we don’t need so many events for navigating the menu. This default behavior made it difficult to select the menu item you want because a slight input would move the cursor several spaces. To remedy this, I made a debounce tool, which helps to prevent many method calls within a short period of time.

public class Debounce {
    static Dictionary<string, float> dict = new Dictionary<string, float>();
    public static bool Test(string name, float delay)
        if (!dict.ContainsKey(name))
            Debug.Log("New debounce key. Adding.");
            dict.Add(name, Time.time + delay);
            return true;

        if (dict[name] < Time.time)
            Debug.Log("Past debounce delay. Refreshing.");
            dict[name] = Time.time + delay;
            return true;

        Debug.Log("Rejecting event repeated too early.");
        return false;

// In Menu Manager
public void OnMenu()
    if (!Debounce.Test("OnMenu", 0.25f)){ return; }

This example only allows the menu toggle function to be called once every 0.25 seconds. This is needed because OnMenu gets called twice for every gamepad button press. I believe this is because the function is bound to keydown and keyup events. I can certainly forsee some more complex solution to this, but the debounce library was a quick fix without much intertangling of classes.

The final version of the menu for this sprint

There was one last issue to deal with: reproducability. This task was about creating prefabs so others can easily create new menus as needed. The way Unity defines prefabs added some friction here. Menus have some deep structure, and the part that needs customization in particular, the contents of the menu, is nested most deeply.

Menus have
a somewhat deep structure
Menus have a somewhat deep structure

Once you have a prefab, you aren’t able to change or rearrange children of that root element. This is a no-go for menus. I had tried duplicating prefabs so each one could have different contents, but this prevents them from getting all the same style updates when the design inevitably changes.

Eventually I found Unity’s Prefab variants, which got the job done. This option allows us to have an empty root menu prefab which contains most of the styling information, then create variants of the prefab which are allowed to have modified children.

The menu
The menu prefab
The pause
menu prefab derived from the generic menu prefab
The pause menu prefab derived from the generic menu prefab

Now updates to the style of the menu will be applied to these implemented menus, and new menus can be created without having to crack apart an existing prefabs.

There is one large remaining issue which I plan to explore over break. These menus are used when the game is paused, which will likely be done with Time.timeScale = 0f. In light of this, the animations need to be run within unscaled time in order to work.

Playtest Data Explorer

At the end of last sprint, there were some big problems with the playtest data explorer. In this sprint, I was able to address several of them.

  1. The on-scene drawings were done in a very hacky and unstable way.
  2. Calls to the data recorder needed to be placed inline in code, making implementation spread out and spaghetti-like.
  3. The only events being logged were jumps
  4. When there were a lot of events to show, the view was crowded.

When I built the initial prototype of this system, I was only aware of the possibility of drawing on the scene with Gizmos. Gizmos can only be drawn by objects that inherit from MonoBehaviours. To perform the drawing this way, I had my editor window create an anonymous GameObject intended only for rendering. This implementation causes problems when running the game preview, occasionally fails for seemingly random reasons, and ultimately just feels wrong.

I was advised by Max that the Handles library can perform the same types of drawing actions and perhaps even more sophisticated ones. The difference is that Handles are drawn by custom editors rather than MonoBehaviours. I was able to port my existing editor window + renderer to a custom editor mostly just by changing the Gizmo drawing statements to Handles ones. I made this editor the custom editor for the component I created to address problem 2.

In order to centralize the data collection calls, I created a component on the player which adds listeners to various UnityEvents on other player components to capture data about the events. The tricky part of this is that UnityEvents aren’t able to pass data. I am only able to know when something has happened, but not anything about what happened. To address this, the component also keeps references to other components and reads the data itself.

Even this fix isn’t quite good enough, though. It’s restrained to being run when the source triggers the event, which could be arbitrary. An example here is the jump event. The jump event is invoked before the DoJump routine is run.

private void DetermineIfCanCoyoteJump () {
	if (playerColl.collInfo.inAir && !jumping && playerVelocity.y < 0f && jumpInputDown &&
		(Time.time <= (playerColl.collInfo.timeLeftGround + coyoteJumpTimer)))
		DoJump(new Vector2(playerVelocity.x, maxJumpVelocity));

if (playerColl.collInfo.onGround) {

	jumpVelocity = new Vector2(playerVelocity.x, maxJumpVelocity);

This means the velocity of the jump isn’t even calculated by the time the logging event which wants to record it is run. We have to wait until the end of the frame to ask the player for it’s new velocity post-jump in order to record the jump.

void LogJump()

delegate void VoidFunc();

IEnumerator WaitThenLog(VoidFunc f)
    yield return new WaitForEndOfFrame();

void LogJumpDirection()
    PlaytestData.LogVector(rigidbody.position, "jump", rigidbody.velocity);

This coroutine approach works, but the whole process would be easier if events were able to pass data to listener functions.

To enhance the collector further, I set up collection for several more events:

  1. Projectile Throw
  2. Teleport
  3. Hazard Collision (Death / Respawn)

My understanding is that gameplay will get more complex and will require logging on different variables, like health events. The benefit of this centralization change is that those kinds of updates will be very easy. I already have listeners for health change events, but there isn’t a playtest example ready for these yet.

playtest with new event logging
Example playtest with new event logging

As shown, with all data being displayed at once, it can be tricky to see particular events you want to focus on. This will only get worse as we collect more data. To help address this, I created checkboxes to toggle the view of every event in a playtest. When unchecked, these events will simply not be rendered.

The new
custom editor with event toggles
The new custom editor with event toggles

There is one more issue that hasn’t really been addressed yet, which is the saving of playtest data for built games. When run in the editor, playtests will save to the assets directory. When built, the game can only write these new files to an obscure, generally hard to access directory which varies based on the operating system. We will still need to talk through the ideal workflow to figure out the solution for this.

As mentioned as the general theme of this post, I think this tool is in a good foundational state. The next step is to work with designers on various pods to figure out exactly what their reporting needs are. Once we address this and the build log issue, it will be ready to put into people’s hands to start collecting playtests!

Game Builds

The automated game builds are still a point of contention. We have a couple competing interests and things haven’t quited played out to a dead end.

First, the studio has access to a Linux server provided by the University. The ideal situation would involve performing the builds and hosting the results from this server. This is possible, but there is a problem. Unity’s Linux editor is capable of making compatible builds for Windows and MacOS, but the game still needs to compile on that platform. This is a problem because the game currently doesn’t build on Linux because of it’s reliance on the Wwise engine. I don’t have good insight into this, but it sounds like Wwise can support Linux, but wasn’t configured that way for our project. The audio lead, Faulkner, has reached out to see about adding this support.

If we are able to build on Linux, I have a Docker container set up already in order to easily install Unity on the server. If this doesn’t pan out, our next option will be to run the build on a virtual Windows machine on AWS. This is a frustrating option because it will cost money and move computation elsewhere. It would be more efficient, free, and a good use of our server for this to not be the case.

Whatever the case ends up being for the platform, thanks to Arbor Interactive, we have a Unity script that will perform the build. Once we have confirmation of the platform, I’ll be able to execute on launching the nightly builder in a minimal amount of time.